Going Backwards

In the 1940 A-movie His Girl Friday, Hildy Johnson (Rosalind Russell) is torn between life as a star newspaper reporter, with her editor boss (Cary Grant), and marriage to a dull mama’s boy (Ralph Bellamy). 

The role of women in society has been slowly evolving.
For most of European and American history, women have been dependent on their fathers or husbands.
There were clear divides.
The wealthy women were ladies of leisure, with some not even tending to their own children.
Some middle-class women kept house, while others took in laundry, assisted in their husbands’ businesses, or did piece work in their homes.
Poor women worked in factories, or were servants.

In The Corpse Vanishes, the bride-stealing Dr Lorenz (Bela Lugosi) threatens the lives of snoopy reporter Patricia Hunter (Luana Walters) and brave medical Dr. Foster (Tristram Coffin). In this 1942 B-movie, the female protagonist gives up her job for marriage.

Movies of the 1920’s through the 1940’s illustrate that the fact of women entering the work force in greater numbers was a major problem for men.
It happened in stages.
At first, women became typists, factory workers, nurses, teachers, and reporters.
A few women ran businesses, usually after their husbands died.
Slowly, women entered more and more male professions, but they always earned less money than men.
1940’s Hollywood script writers observed this “evolution” in the roles of the sexes, and acted by attempting to persuade women that their main societal goal should be marriage and children.

In Bowery at Midnight, evil psychology professor Brenner (Bela Lugosi) threatens the lives of caring society girl Judy Malvern (Wanda McKay, seen above) and her society boyfriend Richard Dennison (John Archer). In this 1942 B-movie, the female protagonist gives up her job for marriage.

By the late 1980’s, thrillers and comedies didn’t conclude with marriage ceremonies.
Instead, in “romantic” films like 1988’s Working Girl and 2009’s The Proposal, “hard-driving” business women were the butt of jokes.
The main point of most of these “romantic comedies” was that business was a cutthroat world, for which women were emotionally “unsuited.” *

One way of thinking about today’s anti-abortion movement is that it isn’t just about preserving human life.
It’s about men being dominant over women.
The current President promises to “protect” and “take care” of American women, whether they “like it or not.”
Not being able to end a pregnancy, and not being able to obtain adequate birth control methods, makes women dependent on the men.
It’s still almost impossible for any poor or middle-class woman to raise a child on her own.

I recently discovered the book Sex and the Constitution.
Geoffrey R. Stone’s book was published in 2017.
Yet, I had not heard of this 668-page book, until I found it in a used book shop.

Cover of Sex and the Constitution, by Geoffrey R. Stone.

In Mr. Stone’s book, I learned that the Supreme Court justices who decided Roe vs Wade, in a 7-2 decision (1973), relied on far different opinions than the justices who overturned Roe vs Wade in 2022.
Indeed, one of the justices (Harry Blackmun) spent hours in the Mayo Clinic Library reviewing books and articles on the history and practice of abortion.
Justice Blackmun asked in his draft opinion:

What. . . did it mean to say that a doctor can legally perform an abortion only to save the life of a woman? Did this mean that the doctor could perform an abortion “only when, without it, the patient will surely die?. . . Must death be imminent?”

Justice Blackmun’s sensitivity to this issue is a far cry from the “precedents” that Justice Samuel Alito relied upon.
While Blackmun, and the other justices, relied on the latest research, Samuel Alito turned to the 1600’s.
In his draft opinion, he quoted from Sir Mathew Hale (1609-1676), the English witchcraft judge who burned witches, and make marital rape legal.

Was Matthew Hopkins (Vincent Price), in 1968’s The Conqueror Worm, a follower of Judge Matthew Hale? The time period does match. This British film was also known as Witchfinder General.

Doctors in the 21 states that are currently banning abortions assume that the death of the woman must be imminent in order for them to provide an abortion.
As a result of Roe vs Wade being overturned, pregnant women are not being treated by medical professionals, but are instead bleeding out in hospital parking lots.

In contrast to Justice Alito who allied himself with witch-killer Justice Hale, Justice Blackmun pointed out that the “criminalization of abortion was a relatively recent phenomenon” in world history. “At the time of the adoption of our Constitution, and throughout the major portion of the 19th century . . . a woman enjoyed a substantially broader right to terminate a pregnancy that she does in most states today.” Justice Blackmun was talking about women in 1972!

In the TV show Murphy Brown, the title character became an unwed mother, and shocked America. In the scene above, Murphy (Candice Bergen) goes into labor during an episode of her newsmagazine series FYI. Murphy Brown ran from 1988-1998, and was revived in 2018.

Another fact that I learned in Sex and the Constitution (about the Roe vs Wade decision), was how Justice William J. Brennon (at that time, the only Catholic Justice on the Court) reconciled his own religious beliefs with his responsibilities as a Supreme Court judge:

I wouldn’t under any circumstances condone an abortion in my private life,” but . . . “that has nothing to do with whether or not those who have different views are entitled to have them and are entitled to be protected in their exercise of them. That’s my job in applying and interpreting the Constitution.

In the 1972 two-part episode, of the sitcom Maude (“Maude’s Dilemma”), Maude Findlay (Bea Arthur) informs her husband (Bill Macy) that she has decided to have an abortion. Some advertisers dropped the show; some affiliates didn’t air reruns of this two-parter.

Although few admit it, Roe vs Wade was a compromise on abortion.
The U.S. Constitution doesn’t allow states to deny freedoms to its’ citizens, in order to accommodate the religious beliefs of other citizens.
Yet, Roe vs Wade did limit a woman’s freedom by protecting the life of her unborn child, and placing that possible life above her own.
Essentially, Roe vs Wade eliminated a woman’s right to an abortion as soon as her potential progeny became viable.
Medical experts should help Congress work out a national abortion policy that fosters the births of viable infants, as well as the health and well-being of their mothers. 

* ”Unsuited” is an interesting word. Does a man-style suit, by design, give a woman authority?

Manipulated?

In Twilight’s Last Gleaming, General Dell (Burt Lancaster) attempts to black mail the American government into revealing Vietnam War atrocities. This 1977 Robert Aldrich film is only available in a British-restored version, on YouTube.

I used to believe that I lived in a stable, democratic (small D) country.
I thought most people wanted the President to be intelligent, as well as ethical.
I also believed that most people realized that Liberals cared a little more about the working class than Republicans.
Today, I worry that most citizens don’t care about anything other than their pocket books.

I was a young person during the 60’s and 70’s.
It was an era of demonstrations in the streets, colleges closing down because four students were killed by the Ohio National Guard (Kent State), and a string of traumatic assassinations.
It was also a period of conspiracy films (1962’s The Manchurian Candidate, 1964’s Seven Days in May, 1973’s Executive Action, and 1977’s Twilight’s Last Gleaming).
Burt Lancaster starred in three of these films! 

In the 2012 documentary Aldrich Over Munich: The Making of ‘Twilight’s Last Gleaming’ (by Robert Fischer), Fischer explains how Twilight came to be produced.
The six-million-dollar film was neither a critical, or a financial, success.
However, star Burt Lancaster, director Robert Aldrich, and the rest of the all-star cast, all hoped that it would spur discussion on the dangers of nuclear war, and the fact that the American Government lied to its’ people.
(The documentary reveals that Burt Lancaster was one of the few friends that Robert Aldrich asked to see, when Aldrich was on his deathbed.)

In 1964’s Seven Days in May, U.S. generals attempt a coup against a President who has negotiated a nuclear disarmament treaty.

I just read Sex and the Constitution, by Geoffrey R. Stone.
In legal-scholar Stone’s book, I learned that it wasn’t just George Washington who feared for the future of his fledgling country.
Other Founders (like Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, and John Adams) also feared that future citizens would simply lack the “passion for the public good” (a quote from John Adams) that’s necessary for self-government to succeed.

In Washington’s Farewell Address (1783), Washington said that only unity could prevent the nation from splintering into many parts, and from “cunning, ambitious, and unprincipled men” usurping “the very engines, which have lifted them to unjust dominion.”

I recently discovered the first volume of A Frenchman in Lincoln’s America, written on 1865 by journalist Ernest Duvergier de Hauranne (1843-1877).
Much like Alexis de Tocqueville (who visited America in 1835), this other young Frenchman visited twenty states, and discussed the American political system with many citizens.
(In short, another political young Frenchman tried to understand this “exotic” country, and reported back to France.)

One of the things that Duvergier de Hauranne noticed (fresh off the boat), was how only English visitors and immigrants were treated with any measure of civility by customs officials.
All other nationalities were treated with suspicion and hostility.

It wasn’t just a matter of American “nativism.”
In “The Invasion of Maryland” chapter, he states:

The great evil of American Democracy is . . . the apathy of the general public. . . . It is conceivable that the individual who is called upon from time to time to express an opinion on some vague, abstract question by silently casting his vote might tire of what he would come to regard as a useless formality. [Italics mine.]

At least 10 million people (who Vice President Harris, and Governor Waltz, expected to vote in the 2024 election) didn’t bother to vote, making Duvergier de Hauranne’s observations about America prescient.

A scene from The Manchurian Candidate, with the American POWs and their captors. In this 1962 film, an American Staff Sergeant, the stepson of a Senator, is kidnapped to Manchuria, and brainwashed into becoming an assassin. The film was remade in 2004.

The Founders believed that Democracy would only succeed if ordinary citizens learned to care about the well-being of their fellow citizens.
By July 4th, 1826, when Jefferson and Adams were on their deathbeds,* democracy looked like a very dicey bet.
John Quincy Adams (John Adam’s son) had been elected president in 1824, even though his rival (Andrew Jackson) had won 99 electoral votes, and Adams had won only 84.
The House of Representatives still ended up giving the presidency to Adams.

In 1920, Republican congressional leaders attempted to impeach Louis F. Post (1849-1928), the assistant Secretary of Labor, because Post only deported 460 people, out of the 1,600 people that J. Edgar Hoover (1895-1972) wanted him to deport.
(Read all about it in William Willrich’s book about immigrant radicals, American Anarchy.)
This book tells the story of how the U.S. government wasted millions pursuing nonviolent immigrant radicals during, and just after, WWI.

As Louis F. Post put it:

To permit aliens to violate the hospitality of this country by conspiring against it is something which no American can contemplate with patience. Equally impatient, however, must any patriotic American be with drastic proceedings on flimsy proof to deport aliens who are not conspiring against our laws and do not intend to.

Diplomat and political scientist, Madeleine Albright (1937-2022), was ambassador to the United Nations from 1993-1997, and Secretary of State from 1997-2001.
During the middle of Trump’s term, she described him as the “first anti-democratic president in modern U.S. history.”
She wrote in Fascism: A Warning (2018):

I wonder now whether we, as democratic citizens, have been remiss in forming the right questions. Maybe we have grown so accustomed to receiving immediate satisfaction from our devices that we have lost patience with democracy’s sluggish pace. Possibly, we have allowed ourselves to be manipulated by hucksters who pledge to deliver the world on a silver platter but have no clue how to make good on their promises.

Dr. Miles J. Bennell (Kevin McCarthy) dodges and attempts to stop cars again in the 1978 version of Invasion of the Body Snatchers. In both films, Dr. Bennell is unable to convince others that the earth has been taken over by aliens.

Sex and the Constitution, A Frenchman in Lincoln’s America, Fascism: A Warning, and American Anarchy, have all make me realize that the seeds of America’s destruction, as a democratic nation, have been sprouting since 1776.
On November 5th, a battle was lost.
We learned what most U.S. voters actually care about.

*One of the ironies of American history, is that Thomas Jefferson and John Adams both died on the same day, July 4, 1826, almost 200 years ago. Adams (at 90) was seven years older than Jefferson.